You Never Miss That Shot In Practice. So Why Do You Miss It When It Counts?

You’ve made that free throw hundreds of times. Then the game comes down to two shots, your hands feel stiff, and suddenly you’re thinking about where to put your elbow. At SPMI, we’ve helped thousands of athletes overcome this pervasive struggle. One of the first things we teach them is how to recognize where their attention goes under pressure, then bring it back to something they can use.
What happens when athletes choke?
Choking happens when pressure causes an athlete to perform well below what they can normally do. Your heart may race, your grip may tighten, or your legs may feel heavy. Some athletes rush to get the moment over with. Others hesitate, second guess a decision, or feel their mind go blank. After a mistake, you may replay it while the next play is already unfolding.
Pressure can pull your attention in two directions. You might get distracted by what the outcome could mean. What if I let my team down? What will my coach think? Or you might turn your attention inward and try to control every part of a movement you usually execute automatically. In experiments using golf putting, researchers Sian Beilock and Thomas Carr found evidence that pressure can disrupt skilled performance by drawing attention to the mechanics of a practiced movement.
Fear of embarrassment, perfectionism, and expectations from coaches or parents can all make a moment feel bigger. Playing with a lead can bring its own pressure. A tennis player who has been swinging freely all match may start guiding the ball once they get close to winning. The shift can feel small, but it changes the way they play.
Jordan Spieth at the 2016 Masters
Jordan Spieth carried a five shot lead into the back nine of the final round at Augusta National. He bogeyed the 10th and 11th holes, then put two balls in the water at the par three 12th and made a quadruple bogey. Danny Willett went on to win, and Spieth tied for second. The sequence shows how quickly an athlete can go from protecting a lead to chasing one. After each mistake, the immediate challenge is getting ready for the next shot while the score and the stakes are changing.
What athletes can do
Build a routine you can repeat under pressure. Before a serve, putt, or free throw, take a breath, pick a target, and use one short cue. A tennis player might look at the outside corner of the service box and think, up and through. Keep the routine short enough to use when you’re nervous. A review of studies across sports found that routines before performance can help under pressure.
Practice the situation that gets to you. If serving out a match makes you tighten up, start practice games at 5–4 with yourself serving. If you rush late free throws, shoot two after a timed drill with teammates watching. Give yourself credit for following your routine and committing to your target. Over time, you’ll learn that you can execute while your heart is still racing.
Have a plan for the seconds after a mistake. Exhale, release the tension in your hands or shoulders, and choose your next action. A soccer player who loses the ball might immediately think, get goal side. Save the detailed technical analysis for a break or after competition, when you have time to make sense of what happened.
What parents can do
Keep your message simple before competition. A young athlete who already feels pressure can hear “This is a big one” as another reason to worry. Try “I’m excited to watch you play.” During competition, pay attention to your reactions after mistakes. A sigh, a grimace, or a shouted correction can draw an athlete’s attention to the sideline when they need it on the game.
Give them a say in when you talk about the performance. On the ride home, ask, “Want to talk about it now or later?” When they’re ready, ask, “What did you notice right before you started to rush?” Then help them identify one thing to practice. If they recovered well after a mistake, tell them exactly what you saw. “You took your time before the next serve” gives them a behavior they can repeat.
If pressure keeps getting in the way of the way you or your young athlete plays in practice, we can help you identify what happens in those moments and build a plan for competition. Book a free 15-minute call with SPMI.
